Best Arrows for Elk Hunting in 2020: Complete Reviews With Comparisons

best arrows for elk hunting
Spread the love

There is no denying that an elk could be one of the biggest game targets you will ever land. While using a regular rifle is fine, many hunters prefer using a bow for a few reasons.

For one, in many jurisdictions, bow hunting will usually happen at times when using a rifle is prohibited.

Another reason is that the most committed hunters will often take on the challenge of killing their game using other methods.

Elk hunting is great if you are looking to stock up your freezer for the long-term.

Plus, for true hunters, there is nothing more rewarding than having a giant elk head hanging up somewhere in your home.

As you may already know, the accomplishments will pay off big time, especially if you get a good clean shot off with your favorite bow.

Using the best arrows for elk hunting gives you the best chances for success, which is why you’d want to find the best of the best ones available.

Comparison Chart

Carbon Express Maxima RED Fletched Carbon Arrows

TY Archery Carbon Arrow Hunting Arrows

Excalibur Firebolt Carbon Arrows

Black Eagle Deep Impact Fletched Hunting Arrows

Feather Fletched Easton XX75 Jazz Aluminum Arrows

Best Arrows for Elk Hunting: Brief Reviews

1. Carbon Express Maxima RED Fletched Carbon Arrows

If you are a committed bow hunter who wants good hunting arrows that fly fast and finish with superior accuracy, these will work perfectly.

The arrows have blazer vanes that are finished in shades of red and black. They are neatly organized and matched based on weight and spine, so you get consistency every single time.

Losing one arrow is fine, but you would be better off with all of them.

With this, you will get six arrows in one neat package, so you can be sure to have those spares handy if and when you need them.


Are you a hunter who wants nothing more than a precise kill shot?

You’ll get exactly that thanks to the Launchpad Precision Nock on this set, which you will find on all Maxima RED arrows.

Thanks to this feature, you will be able to align the arrow and ensure that your shots are accurate every single time.

If precision and accuracy are your goals, this arrow will more than likely meet it. On top of it all, you also get some serious durability.

This also has dynamic spine control, which will help the arrow go the distance even when it’s armed with a broad arrowhead.

You won’t need to load up a smaller head to let this puppy fly far and fast. Plus, it has a blended carbon shaft that will flex well and not break.

When it comes to your shots, accuracy matters, especially if you want a quick, clean kill shot.

It will take a well-timed, accurate shot to bring down an elk. It won’t be easy knocking them down, but you want to be right on the money.

With these arrows, that’s possible.

At 1/10,000 of an inch, you get what could be the most precise accuracy of any arrow out there.

You won’t have to worry about adjusting the arrow so that it’s straight and perfect because the work is done for you. All you have to do is load it up and let it rip.

These will perform the best if and when you’re within 25 to 60 yards of an elk.

If you’ve ever used cheaper arrows before that were of decent quality, these, in particular, will obliterate them in every way.


  • check
    Straight, accurate shots
  • check
    Excellent grouping
  • check
    Great quality arrows
  • check
    Super strong
  • check
    Easy to load with your bow


  • Some arrows may not be fletched properly
  • Weight consistency is questionable for some users

2. TY Archery Carbon Hunting Arrows

Next up, we have the TY Archery Carbon Hunting Arrows.

These arrows are a serious contender for best carbon arrows, and we can see why. They are solid and built to last.

You can bend them, but they will be very difficult to break.


The shaft length is 28 inches, which is pretty decent if you want arrows that can go the distance. Also included are fletchings that will make loading and lining up reasonably easy.

For the price that it’s going for, these arrows are anything but cheap in quality.

While the nocks are not fixed, you can make it adjustable and easily change it up if and when necessary.

As long as you have it all lined up and loaded into your bow with ease, it shouldn’t be a problem.

Another thing that makes these arrows a great buy is the bright colored vanes. They are bright enough to help you find the arrow with ease.

We know how frustrating it can be to lose an arrow after a missed shot in the field. The bright vanes make the difficulty of finding them a lot easier.

The wind could even take it in another direction, and you could lose sight of it if you blink or look off in a different direction.

Also, these arrows are excellent for target practicing. If you are somewhat of a competitive archer, they might be exactly what you’re looking for.

Whether it’s getting good at shooting with the wind in your face or improving your accuracy, these might be the perfect arrows to invest in to upgrade your archery skills.

If you are fairly new to bow hunting, these should be the arrows to go with.

Whether you are target practicing or using them for the real deal, you can make sure that these arrows will get the job done.

They are affordable, durable, and worth every penny when put to good use.


  • check
    Excellent for beginners
  • check
    Affordable for most users
  • check
    Great quality
  • check
    Comes with extra replacement nocks
  • check
    Suitable for bows around 20 pounds


  • Tips and inserts may fall out sometimes
  • Fletch alignments can be a bit off
  • Some fluttering may occur after release

3. Excalibur Firebolt Carbon Arrows

If you are looking for good hunting arrows, the Excalibur Firebolt could be a good match for you.

With this, you get a six-pack of the best carbon arrows that are high in quality, so you don’t need to worry about these easily breaking.


These arrows can do some serious damage, especially if you are using broadheads. Yes, it can take a broadhead that is sharp and fast to easily penetrate through an elk.

Still, you also want the arrow to fly far and fast at consistent distances and speed.  The last thing you want is an arrow that drops short of the mark.

There is no question that the Excalibur Firebolt Carbon Arrows will make sure that every shot counts.

Easy to load, accurate, and reliable are the three things we can say about these arrows.

As far as durability goes, these are pretty tough, too. In fact, they might be the closest you can get to unbreakable, but don’t take our word for it.

Arrows can break apart even when you fire them. That will undoubtedly be a gut punch to any hunter who had their sights on the perfect target and had the best angle to land a kill shot.

Yes, that has happened to many bowhunters, and the disappointment and frustration could not be more painful.

If this has happened to you, don’t let the same thing happen again.

These arrows are second to none when it comes to structural quality, and you’d be insane to pass up the opportunity to grab these for your next hunt.


  • check
    Solid in construction
  • check
    Can go far even with broadheads
  • check
    Very accurate
  • check
  • check
    Easy to line up for accurate shots


  • A bit on the pricey side
  • Inserts may fall apart at times
  • Some have had complaints about the fletching colors

4. Black Eagle Deep Impact Fletched Carbon Hunting Arrows

The Black Eagle Deep Impact Fletched Carbon Hunting Arrows will certainly give you the consistent performance that many bowhunters are looking for.

With 12 of these arrows at your disposal, you might as well be unstoppable when you’re going up against big game targets like elk.


One of the issues that a bowhunter often face is crosswind drifts.

If you experience this too, then these arrows could be the go-to option for you. This will perform in crosswinds and stay the course no matter where you aim.

These arrows provide you with excellent durability while the design is straight down to its most precise measurements, giving you top-quality accuracy.

In short, whether the winds are calm or a bit on the rough side, these arrows are able to get the job done and do so superbly.

Don’t let nature throw your shots off course.

What you want are arrows that are not too heavy or too light. Instead, just enough to keep itself within its intended path, so you don’t miss the shots that matter most.


  • check
    Very accurate and well balanced
  • check
    Excellent groups
  • check
    Strong construction
  • check
    Can stay straight in crosswinds
  • check
    Penetrates nicely with the right arrowheads


  • Outserts may fall off at times

5. Feather Fletched Easton Jazz Aluminum Arrows

Finally, we’ll be taking a look at the Feather Fletched Easton Jazz Aluminum Arrows. What does this set have to offer than others just can’t?


These arrows are probably the most versatile set of arrows on this list. They are perfect for bow weights ranging anywhere from 15 to 50 pounds.

Since they are made from aluminum, you can expect these to be very durable and last many uses.

Also included in the purchase are steel tips that you can easily install. All you have to do is screw them in.

While the color of the feathers varies, they will still perform the same purpose.

They will allow for a better trajectory and, therefore, make it easier to go farther than almost any other arrow you’ve used.

Lastly, you’d be thrilled to know that these arrows are easy to use, and they can fly far when properly loaded.


  • check
    Very durable
  • check
    Excellent trajectory
  • check
    Great for both hunting and target practice
  • check
  • check
    Straight and accurate


  • May get loose when loaded up
  • Screw on points may be hard to secure at times
  • Nocks may break off after 20 shots


1. How heavy should arrow be for elk?

One rule of thumb to be aware of is that the heavier the arrow, the better it will be for big game.

If you are looking for the best arrows for elk, consider looking for ones that weigh 420 grain.

2. What grain broadhead should I use for elk?

Weight can be a difference-maker when it comes to hunting big game.

If you are hunting elk, consider installing broadheads that weigh approximately 125 grain.

If you want to go lighter, you can try going as low as 100 grain for best results.

3. How much kinetic energy is needed to kill an elk?

At a minimum, the amount of kinetic energy needed to kill an elk is 1,500 feet per pound.

That is 500 pounds more in energy than killing a whitetail deer at its minimum, which is 1,000 FPP.

Final Verdict

Now that you’ve got a look at the five best arrows for elk hunting, you can make a decision based on what you like.

Now, if you’re still having a hard time, we have some recommendations that you can consider.

The first ones we recommend is the Carbon Express Mantra RED Fletched Carbon.

These were designed to provide you with the most precise accuracy possible. What’s more, it can travel a little farther than the others.

Not to mention, they are easy to find in the field. Hence, if you hate losing your arrows while hunting, go for the fletching with a brighter color like what these ones provide.

Our second choice for those looking for something more affordable is the TY Archery Carbon Arrows.

They are solid in construction and work well with beginners. Plus, you can easily install the nocks so that you can make setting it up a lot easier.

In the end, what’s important is that you find the best arrows for elk that will best fit your needs and personal preferences.

Also, consider your budget and your options that coincide with it.

Quality and performance should always hold more value over price, so find the best that you can afford in those regards.

Click here to add a comment

Leave a comment: