Best Fixed Broadhead for Crossbow in 2020: Complete Reviews With Comparisons 

best fixed broadhead for crossbow
Spread the love

While some hunters may be divided about this, fixed broadheads for crossbows are generally considered more efficient.

Besides maintaining the pivotal energy as they come in contact with the target, fixed broadheads also give the best cut.

As for accuracy and wound passage, fixed broadheads are hard to compete with.

There are different builds of broadheads that make it complicated for a new hunter to choose one.

Hence, we’ll help you select the best fixed broadhead for crossbows to take your hunting game up a notch.

Comparison Chart

Cold Steel Cheap Shot Polymer Archery Broadheads

Wasp Drone Broadhead Archery

Excalibur Boltcutter 150 Grain 3-Blade Broadhead

Slick Trick Broadhead

New Archery Products Hellrazor 60-410 Broadheads

Best Fixed Broadhead for Crossbows

1. Cold Steel Shot Polymer Archery Broadhead

The Cold Steel Polymer Broadhead is a spin on the conventional steel arrows.

Being a polymer-based broadhead, it’s more affordable than steel broadheads while offering almost similar accuracy. 

Product Highlights

Despite being polymer-based, the Cold Steel Shot Archery Broadhead features top-notch precision.

It is ideal for hunting raccoons, coyotes, and varmints.

The space-age polymer acts as a substitute for stainless steel, reducing the price without significantly affecting the performance.

While steel is prone to rusting and tarnishing, the polymer can sustain wear and tear gracefully in the outdoors.

The Good 

We love that the broadhead features Cold Steel’s patented Grip n’ Rip serrations that can cut through fibrous tissues and flesh.

Additionally, it’s more affordable than steel broadheads. Since there are ten pieces in a set, it’s easy to replace them as required.

Regardless of the weather conditions, the polymer broadheads will neither retain physical damage nor be affected by the wind pressure.

As soon as they’re out of the crossbow, they reach the target without a miss.

The Bad

While these Cold Steel broadheads do a fantastic job of tearing through the smaller game, they’re not your best bet for deer or similar animals.

Being made of polymer, they’re not strong enough to break a bone. 

Moreover, the broadheads are only suitable for short-range shooting.

Anything past 20 yards won’t get the same results as close-distance shots. 

PROS

  • Affordable
  • High precision
  • Does not rust or tarnish
  • Perfect for small game hunting

CONS

  • Not suitable for larger animals
  • Does not cut through bones
  • Only for short-range shooting

2. Drone Broadhead by Wasp Archery

A product by Wasp Archery, the Drone Broadhead is a solid steel tool for experienced hunters.

Manufactured in the USA, every component is tested for quality.

Product Highlights

Like all other heads made by the company, the Wasp Archery Drone Broadhead is pressed with a force of hundreds of pounds to flatten it properly.

Owing to this, every shot moves with ultimate precision without risk of unwanted interference in its trajectory.

The Wasp Archery Drone Broadhead also has an aerodynamic design.

The three-blade head lines up nicely with the trocar tips.

As such, you can experience a cut-on-contact delivery that’s bound to make the animal drop to the ground immediately.

Since there’s a steel ferrule on the Wasp Archery Drone Broadhead, it ensures a neat pass-through.

Thus, no deer or elk stands a chance against this broadhead.

The Good

We love that the Wasp Archery Drone Broadhead has a 100% steel construction as it guarantees durability and quality.

Additionally, the ferrule surface has been reduced to ensure the highest accuracy and penetration.

Owing to the well-balanced construction, the broadhead has a dart-like flight.

Plus, the trocar tip is hardened and hollow-ground enough to move through even the toughest material, like bones.

The 0.27-inch razor-sharp blades are also honed to improve penetration.

The Bad

In some cases, the broadhead would not hit the same impact point as the field point. 

That could be a bit of a problem if you’re hoping for unmatched accuracy. 

Additionally, the blades aren’t reusable and tend to break on the first usage. 

PROS

  • Accurate and precise
  • Durable
  • Offers cut-on-contact delivery
  • Neat pass-through
  • Penetrates tough materials

CONS

  • Does not come with a practice head
  • Fluctuates in point of impact
  • Non-reusable blades

3. Excalibur Boltcutter Broadhead

The Excalibur Boltcutter Broadhead is one of the company's finest products.

It boasts a stainless steel construction and a high-strength functionality.

Product Highlights

The Excalibur Boltcutter Broadhead is a 150-grain tool that is ideal for the high-speed crossbows you find in the market today.

Despite the extreme range, the broadhead offers top-notch accuracy when combined with a suitable arrow.

Made purely of solid steel, it is strong enough to cut through bone, flesh, skin, and tissue.

The high-strength stainless steel bears the hardest hits with grace, delivering terminal performance to make your hunting experience a success.

The Good

Excalibur products are a top choice among hunters, but they’ve surpassed their own standard with this Boltcutter broadhead.

It has a one and 1/16" cutting head, which is suitable for hunting smaller animals and larger games alike.

Moreover, the high-strength construction allows you to use the broadhead in any weather condition and any animal.

Most importantly, the Excalibur Boltcutter Broadhead is specifically designed for faster crossbows. 

As such, you don’t have to settle for a sub-par broadhead for your high-speed bow anymore.

The Bad

The Excalibur Boltcutter Broadhead comes in a pack of six. Often, not all of them are totally accurate.

While three or four of them are completely reliable, the remaining two might not be worth risking on a deer or elk.

Also, the assembly is a bit tricky. So, if you’re an amateur or still learning, you’ll definitely need some help with the broadhead.

PROS

  • Refined cutting head
  • Designed for high-speed hunting crossbows
  • Easy to replace blades
  • Penetrates tough materials

CONS

  • Tricky assembly
  • Fluctuating accuracy
  • Higher price point

4. Slick Trick Broadhead

The Slick Trick Broadhead is a multi-use tool suitable for crossbows, recurve bows, and compound bows.

Although versatile in terms of performance, the broadhead is especially efficient at hunting bears. 

Product Highlights

The first thing you’d notice about this broadhead is the size, which is its highlighting feature.

Owing to the smaller build, the Slick Trick Broadhead soars through the air like a dart and hits the target almost every time.

Having four in a pack, the broadheads are designed to have an impeccable flight.

On top of them, they have a fixed-blade design that passes completely through the thickest flesh and skin.

The Good

Possibly the best thing about the Slick Trick Broadhead is the low-profile design.

Besides delivering better maneuverability, the design also allows the broadhead to cut through the air without interference.

Even if you’re using it on a modern crossbow with a blistering speed, the broadhead will keep up with the bow’s velocity.

It will reach the target even when shot from a longer range.

Having said that, the Slick Trick Broadhead can easily pass through a bear from 45 yards away.

The Bad

Although the broadheads fly great, they have a small cutting diameter.

Depending on the arrow you’re using, this could impact penetration.

Since it has a smaller entry, the Slick Trick Broadhead does not create a bigger wound in the flesh.

PROS

  • Low-profile design
  • Works well with high-speed crossbows
  • Compatible with compound bows
  • Long-distance shot

CONS

  • Blades don’t fit comfortably
  • Small cutting diameter
  • Leaves a smaller wound

5. New Archery Products Hellrazor Broadheads

The New Archery Products Hellrazor Broadheads comes in a pack of three.

These are 100-grain tools with stainless steel construction.

Product Highlights 

First and foremost, the Hellrazor broadheads have a one-piece design that’s ultra-strong to match experienced hunters' needs.

Owing to the stainless steel construction, you can use the broadheads in any setting without worrying about physical or mechanical damage.

The photon blade bonding of the New Archery Products Hellrazor Broadheads further adds strength. 

As for the consistency, the blade takes care of that too.

Since there are three broadheads in a pack, replacement is a breeze, especially on an extended hunting trip.

The Good 

The best thing about the New Archery Products Hellrazor Broadheads is that it leaves a fantastic blood trail when you hit your target.

If you’re a pro and know how to place them properly in an arrow, you’ll have the cleanest kills that you could wish for.

Additionally, the broadheads are extremely well-made and work with most modern crossbows.

The 0.027-inch blade easily cuts through flesh, bone, and skin while the one-and-1/8 inches cutting diameter leaves an appreciable wound.

The Bad

As amazing as these broadheads are in terms of flight accuracy and precision, they fall behind in sharpness.

If you don’t sharpen them beforehand, the blades will be too dull to cut through a deer.

Sure enough, you can use them for hunting smaller games, but elk and bear will require extensive blade sharpening. 

Although it shouldn’t be much of a hassle, the high price point makes the dullness totally unjustified.

PROS

  • Leaves an excellent blood trail
  • Clean kills
  • Delivers superior precision and accuracy
  • Easy to replace blades 

CONS

  • Extremely dull
  • Cannot kill bigger animals without sharpening

How To Choose the Best Broadheads for Crossbows

Buying a fixed broadhead for your crossbow is just as important as investing in a dependable crossbow.

You will get an impressive shot only if the arrow, bow, and broadhead are in perfect alignment.

Before you purchase a broadhead, you have to ask yourself a few questions, such as:

  • Which animal will you be hunting?Do you prefer long-range shooting over short-range?
  • Are you ready to give polymers a try over steel construction? 

Still, it can be a bit overwhelming to choose your go-to broadhead because there are tons of options from companies that specialize in hunting gear.

Let’s discuss a few features that will help you decide if a broadhead is suitable for you.

Style

Typically, broadheads come in three styles: mechanical blade, fixed blade, and hybrid broadheads.

Since we’re focusing on fixed blades, let’s talk about them in detail.

These blades could either be designed as a solid one-piece or a ferrule with separate blades.

In the latter case, the blades are replaceable while the former holds up better in terms of durability because they are made of a single material.

The major difference between these two kinds is sharpness.

When one-piece blades become dull, you have to sharpen them.

In contrast, you can replace the dull blades with new ones if you’re using a broadhead with a ferrule.

Also, replaceable blades come in two- to four-blade configuration, providing extreme robustness.

Cut

The cut of a broadhead is measured in two ways: cutting diameter and total cut.

  • Cutting Diameter

The cutting diameter refers to the delivery cut's width, while the total cut combines the length of the blades’ surface area.

Here’s an example: if a fixed broadhead has four blades. 0.5 inches each, the total cut would add up to two inches.

That’s what you get when you add the lengths of the four blades.

Meanwhile, the broadhead would have a cutting diameter of one inch because that’s the delivery cut's width, which is only made by two blades.

Although there isn’t a lot of difference in the total cut of fixed broadheads and mechanical ones, the cutting diameter differs for both.

Mostly, fixed blade broadheads have a limited cutting diameter.

Number of Blades

When buying a fixed blade broadhead, you must consider the number of blades since they increase the cut and affect friction.

Firstly, the blades increase the total cut. Don’t confuse it with diameter, though.

As the total cut increases, the chances of your shot slicing through the target increase too.

The blades also increase friction. If there are too many blades on a broad head, they’ll interfere with the flight and create pass-through issues.

However, more blades mean a larger cutting surface and a bigger wound.

They also increase the chances of penetration and severing arteries of the vital organs.

If you’re leaning more towards a deeper penetration, opt for a two-blade configuration.

That's because it creates a perfect balance between friction and penetrance.

For hunters who prefer low poundage, a broadhead with a low profile and small diameter is the ideal pick.

For instance, the Slick Trick Broadhead in our list has a low-profile design, so it's suitable for lighter arrows.

On the other hand, three- and four-blade configurations are dependable for heavier arrows.

If you want the target to suffer more blood loss and retain a larger wound, invest in a three- or a four-blade broadhead.

Weight 

Since the crossbow and the arrow will contribute to the final weight, you must consider the broadhead’s weight to attain a set up that you can comfortably work with.

Consider the following key factors when choosing the weight of the broadhead: 

  • Use

Even if you buy the best broadheads for crossbows, if they don't match their specific use, then they'll be useless.

If you’re hunting smaller game, you can opt for lighter broadheads since they offer maximum pass through.

On the contrary, you should buy heavier broadheads for larger animals.

That's because they deliver more kinetic energy to allow better penetration.

  • Crossbow Bolt

You should also keep the bolt weight and length in mind when choosing a broadhead.

Although lighter broadheads tend to fly like darts, they don’t deliver an optimal front of the center.

Thus, they can fluctuate accuracy. 

  • Crossbow Built

Finally, you must check the crossbow’s specifications before buying a broadhead.

For example, a heavier broadhead may not be able to work with your crossbow. 

A certain weight may also add more stress to the crossbow, affecting flight and precision.

Leading Edge

Hunters often ignore the broadhead tip, but it’s something you must factor in when buying hunting gear.

If you want to get the best penetration and a clean pass-through, go for a razor tip.

The New Archery Products Hellrazor Broadheads on our list is the best crossbow broadhead for deer owing to the reason mentioned above.

For the smaller game, you can work with a blunt tip.

It won’t pass through completely, saving meat while providing efficient delivery and flight.

Cost

The cost shouldn’t be much of an issue, considering most fixed blade broadheads have similar price points.

If you want to get a better pass through, don’t hesitate to spend some extra bucks on steel broadheads.

Profile

The shape of a broadhead will affect the penetration depth and the size of the wound.

Nowadays, you can easily find broadheads with different profiles, including those reminiscent of the traditional stone heads used by Native Americans.

Likewise, you can find modern profiles that resemble fighter jets.

Keep in mind that slim profiles will be more durable.

Plus, they don’t cause major meat loss when hunting small animals.

You can also use them with larger animals such as elk to achieve maximum penetration through the dense muscle mass.

A broader profile makes the best crossbow broadhead for deer since it creates a large wound and makes the animal bleed out quickly.

If you’re hunting animals with soft tissue mass, look for broadheads with a broader profile.

FAQs About Crossbow Broadheads

1. Are broadheads different for crossbows?

Generally, you can use any archery broadhead with a crossbow.

The only difference between regular broadheads and those specific for crossbows is the arrow speed.

For instance, the best arrows for elk hunting are made to be speedy to match the animal’s mobility.

Since modern crossbows are quite speedy, you may find it difficult to get your desired accuracy and velocity with archery broadheads.

As such, you’ll be better off working with crossbow broadheads that match the bow’s speed.

2. Can you shoot fixed broadheads from a crossbow?

Most crossbows for deer hunting have sufficient kinetic energy to open any kind of broadhead, provided the target distance is 40 yards or lesser.

Having said that, there’s no doubt that you can shoot a fixed broadhead from a crossbow.

Just be careful about the crossbow speed, arrows, and the animals you’re shooting.

That said, if you figured out your setup, shooting fixed broadheads shouldn’t be a problem.

Generally, fixed blades have a one-inch diameter and a killer flight.

Thus, once you learn how to place the arrow, the one-inch cut should be able to kill the largest of animals, including bears.

3. What grain of broadhead should I use?

Typically, you’ll find fixed blade broadheads ranging from 75 grains to 300 grains.

The 100-grain option is the most popular. That’s because it has a lightweight design that allows it to move through the air pretty easily.

If you’re using a crossbow, don’t go for heavier grains since the 300-mark is only ideal for shooters who use compound bows.

With the heavier heads, the arrows’ spines get weaker, disrupting the accuracy.

Most crossbows for beginners work well with 100-grain broadheads, but you can get better results with 125-grain versions.

Pro tip: as the grain increases, the weight goes higher, and so does the penetration.

4. Are fixed blade or mechanical broadheads better?

Keeping it brief, fixed blade broadheads are more reliable and have better penetration.

The problem is they suffer in terms of accuracy.

On the contrary, mechanical broadheads boast superior cutting, accuracy, and blood trails but lack penetration.

Speaking of strength, mechanical broadheads take second place.

The fixed blade broadheads tend to be stronger.

In contrast, mechanical broadheads stay in place with a single screw only. As a result, they’re more prone to breaking.

You should choose the broadheads based on the animal you’re shooting.

While mechanical ones are suitable for larger game, the fixed blade broadheads do a fantastic job for hunting raccoons or deer.

5. Should I practice with broadheads?

Yes, it would help if you practice with broadheads before the hunting season.

Normally, broadheads are quite consistent these days. 

Practicing with broadheads can help ensure accurate flight during the hunting season, especially when working with fixed blade broadheads.

It will also help enhance the field point and ensure the broadheads are hitting the vitals.

Final Verdict 

Wrapping up, we’d say that the Excalibur Boltcutter Broadhead is the visible choice for hunters who want to couple speed with a larger cut.

More importantly, this broadhead will give an accurate delivery even in a less than perfect hit.

That said, if you want to save a few bucks, go for the Cold Steel Shot Polymer Archery Broadhead.

Although it doesn’t cut through bones, it’s still the best fixed broadhead for crossbows if you’re shooting small game.

Make sure to revisit this guide to prepare yourself in time for the next hunting season!

Click here to add a comment

Leave a comment: